Contact Us

Indoor Air Quality

There are a lot of products that claim to really clean your indoor air, but how do you know which ones really work?
Comparing the clean air delivery rate is a great place to start. The clean air delivery rate is the amount of clean air a system will deliver into your home for a typical 3-ton system as compared to other whole-house and appliance air cleaners. Two factors affect this rating-the efficiency of the filter material and the amount of air that passes through the device. This standard has been recognized by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and American National Standards Institute (ANSI) as a fair and objective comparison of various air cleaning technologies.

Below is a comparison chart from Consumers Reports in summer of 2005. Note: At the time of this report the Trane Clean Effects was not available yet. Based on studies from other groups, since it's introduction to the market we are sure it would have made the top of this list.

Key numbers with a
indicate Quick Picks.

In performance order
Excellent
Very good
Good
Fair
Poor
 

Brand & model

Price

Annual cost

Type

Overall score

Test results

Similar models in small type, comparable to tested model




Text here
Text here
Text here
 

PROFESSIONALLY INSTALLED These performed best overall

1

AprilAireŽ 5000

$600 $44 EP/F
2

Carrier AIRA

500 30 EP
3

Trion SE1400

700 32 EP
4

Trane Perfect Fit TFE210A9FR3

600 19 EP
5

Honeywell F50 F300

600 21 EP
6

Lennox >Healthy Climate EAC-14 EAC-16, EAC-20

400 13 EP
7

Lennox PureAir PCO-12C PCO-20C

1,100 309 F
8

AprilaireŽ 2200 2400

350 33 F
 

DO-IT-YOURSELF These replace existing filters; annual cost reflects replacement intervals.

9

American Air Filter Dirt Demon Ultra High Efficiency

$30 120 F
10

Filtera MERV 13 Mini Pleat

57 228 F
11

3M Filtrete Ultra Allergen Reduction 1250

15 60 F
12

3M Filtrete Micro Allergen Reduction 1000

12 48 F
13

3M Filtrete Dust & Pollen Reduction 600

10 40 F
14

Precisionaire NaturalAire Elite Lysol Elite, Arm & Hammer Elite

13 52 F
15

The WEB Hepa-Pure

30 30 F
16

Purolator PuroPleat Ultra (PPD)

7 28 F
17

American Air Filter Dirt Demon UltraPleat Ultra Shield

9 20 F
18

American Air Filter Dirt Demon Pleated Dirt Demon Dust Shield

5 8 F
19

Precisionaire NaturalAire Plus Ace Pleated

4 20 F
20

American Air Filter Strata Density Premium

1 11 F
21

Precisionaire EZ Flow

2 22 F
22

The WEB Original

20 F
23

Purolator PuroPleat(Pur 40)

6 24 F
24

American Air Filter ElectroKlean

10 F

Discontinued, but similar model is available. Price is for similar model.

Uses disposable filter insert.


4 in. thick (1 in. for others tested). Washable filter. Cost includes UV lights, which were not tested for performance.

For More Information

Clean indoor air is a major health issue that is receiving increasing attention from physicians, government agencies and families. For more information about what clean air means for you and your family, visit the following links:

American Academy of Allergy Asthma & Immunology
Staying Ahead of Spring Allergy Season

American Lung Association
Improving Life One Breath at a Time

Allergen information
2005 Spring Allergy Capitals

Allergy & Asthma Network Mothers of Asthmatics
Welcome to Breatherville, USA

US Environmental Protection Agency
Basic Information About Indoor Air Quality